A Hoppe Guide to Popular Christmas Tree Varieties

Not all Christmas trees are created equal. When you head to a tree farm or lot this holiday season, you’ll likely see a few varieties over and over - and for good reason. Each has its own strengths (and some trade-offs). Knowing the differences can help you pick a tree that lasts, smells great, and fits your home style. Below, we highlight three of the most popular real Christmas trees: balsam fir, Fraser fir, and Scotch pine. 

Balsam Fir - The Classic Holiday Smell

• Why people love it: Balsam fir is famous for its rich, evergreen scent - that deeply nostalgic "Christmas tree smell" many of us crave.

• What to know: While the smell is top-notch, balsam fir tends to drop needles as it dries out, especially if it doesn't get enough water. That makes regular watering essential.

• Best for: Homes where scent matters most - especially if you bring the tree inside soon after cutting and staying on top of watering.

Fraser Fir - The High End Choice

• Why people love it: Fraser fir is often considered the "premium" Christmas tree. It has a very appealing shape, strong branches, and excellent needle retention - meaning fewer needles on the floor and a sturdier base for ornaments.

• What to know: It may not smell quite as strong as a balsam fir, but the trade-offs are worth it for many: a longer-lasting tree that looks great and supports heavy ornaments without drooping.

• Best for: Families with lots of ornaments, heavier decorations, or those who want their tree looking full and beautiful well past Christmas Day.

Scotch Pine (Scots Pine) - The Value Pick

• Why people love it: Scotch pine is often the most budget-friendly real tree - reliable and affordable. Its needles are famous for being durable: they stay on the tree even when it dries out.

• What to know: Though not as fragrant as balsam or as "luxurious" as Fraser, Scotch pine delivers solid value. Its dense, bright-green needles and sturdy branches make it a good choice if you want a no-fuss tree with good longevity.

• Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers, first-time real-tree buyers, or anyone wanting a simple, classic evergreen that stays neat with minimal care.

Choosing a Tree: What Matters

When picking a Christmas tree, it's more than scent or aesthetics. Think about:

• Needle retention & maintenance: If you don't want to vacuum needles for weeks, go for Fraser fir or Scotch pine over balsam.

• Ornaments & decorations: For heavy ornaments or a full layered look, Fraser fir's sturdy branches are ideal.

• Budget & value: Scotch pine gives you a sturdy, decent-looking tree at a lower price, while Fraser fir is more of a long-term investment for a high-quality holiday display.

• Scent & tradition: If the smell of a real tree is part of the holiday tradition for you, balsam fir often wins the heart (and nose).

Didn't Know - Wisconsin's Big Role in the Christmas Tree Industry

Here's a fun local fact: Wisconsin ranks top five in the nation for Christmas tree production.

• The state grows hundreds of thousands of trees each year (many balsam firs, Fraser firs, and Scotch pines among them).

• Buying a real tree helps support local farms, family businesses, and contributes significant money to the local economy.

So when you choose a real tree this season - especially from a local grower - you're not just bringing home Christmas spirit. You're supporting Wisconsin's agricultural heritage.

Whether you go for the fragrant Balsam, the elegant Fraser, or the budget-friendly Scotch pine, real Christmas trees each bring their own charm. The "best" tree depends on what matters most to your family: scent, appearance, longevity, or price. Enjoy your Christmas tree while it lasts - when it's time to say goodbye, we can chip it for a fee!

At Hoppe Tree Service, we believe there's no wrong choice - just the right tree for you. Happy Holidays from Hoppe Tree Service!